I've been crocheting for a very long time (55 years) and think I'm experienced enough to talk about the differences in crochet hooks. The 2 most popular brands are Susan Bates and Boye. I used to never think about the differences in these 2 hooks until about 18 years ago, when it just hit me! My Susan Bates hooks are more comfortable in my hands and if for some reason I need to use one of my Boye hooks because I can't find the size I need in the SB brand, it just feels so awkward to use the Boye brand hooks. I think I finally figured out why.
I have very small hands. In fact, smaller than the average women. I wear a size 3½ ring on my "ring" finger and that's the size of my engagement ring and wedding band. I can never, ever find rings to fit me! I wear a size 4 on my right hand and that size is not easy to find either. So it's safe to say my fingers are the size of small girls fingers. I've actually tried my 3½ size rings on the hands of 5 year old girls and they actually fit! I'm not saying they don't exist, but I've never found another woman who has fingers as small as mine. But now, 2 of my granddaughters, ages 21 and 25 can get my size 3½ rings on their left ring finger. I guess they take after me.
But back to the crochet hooks, the "shaft" of the Susan Bates hooks are shorter than the shaft of Boye hooks. If you don't know which part of the hook is the "shaft", it's the part from the "thumb rest" to the "throat" of the hook. See the illustration below showing the different parts of a crochet hook. This illustration came from "Cranberry Crochet" and if you want to read more, click on the link below.
| Parts of a Crochet Hook |
Anther reason I think Susan Bates are more comfortable in my hands is because I use the "Pencil hold". When I learned to crochet at 18 years old in a college class, we were taught to use the Pencil hold. Actually, back then, in 1968, I had no idea there was any other way to hold the hook. When I found out several years later that some people held their hook like they'd hold a knife, (called the knife hold), I thought they were doing it wrong because I'd never seen that before.
I also have a theory as to why some people have problems with pain in their hand and wrist, such as Carpal Tunnel Syndrome. For more info on that, see my post HERE.
Cranberry Crochet:
https://cranberrycrochet.com/7-parts-of-a-crochet-hook-you-need-to-know/
https://youtu.be/uXR2T3QFf_g











